Sunday, January 27, 2013

Hospice "Under-Use"

The end-of-life care system in the United States is not part of the health care system that often gets high reviews.  We have a system of hospice care that can be used to facility what some call a "high quality dying experience," although whether it is important to have a high quality experience of approaching death or to having on until very end and have what some consider to be a "lower quality dying experience" is a matter of opinion.  In other words, what constitutes a high quality dying experience is a matter of opinion.  Not everyone's utility (or their family members' utility) is maximized by the same choices.

Still, many think of hospice care as potentially less expensive, providing better management of the condition approaching death, and providing an opportunity for family of the dying individual to manage their own interests better.  In that case, the quantity of hospice care demanded is often perceived to be "less than what would be expected".  For a long time people have asked why.

Many reasons have been given.  Perhaps people don't understand hospice.  Perhaps patients of their families have a disutility of even dealing with the hospice decision as it means that they are admitting that they are close to death.  Perhaps providers have a disutility of discussing the issue with patients.

Or, perhaps, according to a news piece featured in the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health news feed last week (the news piece can be found here: http://www.upi.com/Health_News/2013/01/25/Hospice-under-use-due-to-enrollment-rules/UPI-85761359090049/) the reason is an even more basic economic one.

The news piece reports on an article in Health Affairs (a very good health policy journal) that was worked on by a colleague of mine, Colleen Barry.  The work found that many hospice care facilities have rules that limit enrollment opportunities for patients with more complex needs.  This is more likely to be true in facilities that are smaller and for-profit.  Some, one may question the profit and the capacity of some hospice facilities.

This raises the interesting question about whether a focus on demand side policy interventions is misplaced.  In other words, should we be educating families more?  Should we be educating physicians more?  Should we be working on improving the decision making process?  Or should we, instead, be focused on changing incentives for the supply side?

No definitive answer here, but it does give us something to think about.  The news piece says that the Health Affairs article suggests that Medicare could consider raising the per day reimbursement rate for complex patients.  The big question--would that solve the problem or create new ones by making it easier for more people to enroll.  

2 comments:

  1. Visiting Angels is indeed a blessing. I needed someone to care for my mom who lives in Palm Beach Gardens, FL. She suffers from Alzheimer’s and I live in England. I was able to choose the right caregiver for my Mom. The person was experienced and had excellent credentials. I have peace of mind knowing that Mom is in capable hands. You should check them out at www.visitingangels.com/palmbeaches (561-328-7611) if you need senior care services.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Superbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place..
    Hi5 Boost

    ReplyDelete